Nora comes to the meeting with damp sleeves. She has been helping Sofia clear a return pipe in the growing room, and the water has reached well past her elbows. She takes the chair beside mine, pulls the fabric away from her wrists and asks whether everyone has seen it yet.
“Only the first image,” I say.
“Then wait. Let me get settled.”
We are in the colony's common room, an hour after Katja requested the meeting.
Morrow has prepared the observations for transmission to Earth as well. That record will take three hundred and twenty-five years to reach them. If someone answers immediately, the reply will spend the same time coming back. We will have to decide what to send to the asteroid long before anyone at home can offer instructions. Eleven months of use have supplied the room with mismatched chairs, a long table and several arrangements of flowering stems that the children make from coloured fibre. One leans against my elbow. I move it towards the centre as Jack and Katja come in together.
Erik has brought Leila. Amara is already seated at the far end, and Sofia arrives carrying the dry top Nora asked her to fetch. There are other adults standing by the open door. They bring chairs in when Erik waves them forward.
Katja sits, then gets up again. She pushes her hair behind both ears.
“I want you to see the observations before I tell you what we think.”
Morrow offers the record through our interfaces. I accept it and attend to the image in my mind's eye. The table remains beneath my hands; I can still hear a chair being dragged into position behind me. Nothing in the recording looks like the machine I have been imagining on the way here.
There is broken rock and a cutting tool held clear of it. Beneath the chipped stone lies a patch of dark metal, almost circular in the wider view. One side remains covered; elsewhere the irregular lip of the excavation overlaps its edge. The centre rises slightly towards the instrument. I think of a ball seen through a hole in a wall.
Morrow provides a second angle. The metal is charcoal grey until the pale reflection crosses it. A thin fringe of violet and green follows, then vanishes. The surrounding rock stays dull and grainy. There is no scratch in the visible metal, no seam, no opening that would give me a front or a back.
For scale, Morrow marks the cutter's reach. The patch grows much larger in my understanding. I have been imagining something I could pick up. The proposed continuation of the curve would make the whole object wider than this room's doorway and taller than any of us.
I keep that completed ball beside the recording, where Morrow has labelled it as a possible shape. The stone has not become transparent. We are looking at a small part of something still buried.
“That is a change in viewing angle,” Morrow says through the room's sound system. “The object has not moved.”
The sequence continues through an early reconstruction and its correction. Three nested curves become one irregular boundary. I feel a small disappointment before remembering that I have no idea what the three curves would have meant.
“Those aren't really there,” Katja says. “Keep the correction in mind for the next part. We were wrong about them.”
As the angle changes, I begin waiting for an opening to appear. None does.
“A sphere?” I ask.
“A spherical surface fits what we can measure,” Morrow says. “If that shape continues, its diameter is approximately five to six metres. We have not observed the hidden portion.”
“So we haven't found the lid.”
“Or established that it has one,” Katja says.
I had been thinking of the great black monolith in 2001. This object has none of its severe corners, but I am old enough for the association to arrive before my better judgment. I remember people approaching it with their hands out.
“Please tell me the cutter didn't touch it.”
“It stopped in the surrounding rock,” Morrow says.
Jack looks across at me. “We've managed the first sensible thing. Let's see if we can keep that going.”
Jack watches Katja while the rest of us watch the record. When she finally sits, he moves her chair a little closer to the table without interrupting her.
“Something built that,” Nora says.
“Yes,” Katja replies. “That's what the measurements point to.”
“One of our earlier missions?” I ask.
“No.” She looks around the table. “We believe this is an alien probe.”
For a moment I keep examining the same circular patch. I have spent much of my life expecting that someone would find evidence of another civilisation. Expecting it has always included the possibility that I would die first, or that the evidence would arrive as an announcement from very far away. Now Katja is sitting opposite me, waiting for us to catch up, and Nora has stopped trying to dry her sleeves.
Leila asks to see the comparison that excludes our equipment.
Morrow supplies it. The known mission records give no match, either here or among the machines humanity has sent ahead. The structure extends under rock that was intact before our cutter reached it. There is no route by which loose material from the mining equipment could have produced what we are seeing.
“That establishes it was here before this cut,” Leila says. “What excludes an object we simply have no record of?”
“The way the material responds,” Katja says. “The shape. And where we found it. None of those is enough on its own.”
She asks Morrow for the two instruments' measurements. I let the shapes recede and follow the comparison it offers instead. I understand the broad differences; the detailed curves mean very little to me until she explains them.
“The survey used weak illumination. This is the light coming back from the same patch at different angles and wavelengths. We can fit parts of it with materials we know how to make. But change the model to match this view, and it stops matching that one.”
“Including structures within the material?” Jack asks.
“Yes,” Morrow says. “Layered materials and other manufactured arrangements are included. The instruments also observed known reference targets. Those results agree with their expected responses; the discrepancy follows the exposed strip.”
“So it isn't just missing from a catalogue,” Nora says.
Katja shakes her head. “We don't know how to make something that behaves this way. We can't yet explain what it's made of. I'm not suggesting a new element. We don't have a good enough account of the material yet.”
“Could a natural formation do it?” I ask.
“I tested several,” Morrow replies. “They fail to explain the surface geometry and the material response together. Manufacture accounts for what we have observed much more closely. It does not tell us who manufactured it.”
Katja rests both hands on the table. “Put the shape, the material and where we found it together. We can't explain it as something humans made. As far as we can establish, this was made by someone else.”
There is a sound from the doorway, somebody releasing a long breath. Nora puts her hand over mine. I turn mine beneath it and hold on.
Amara leans forward. “Why a probe?”
“A working name,” Katja says. “We don't know its purpose.”
“Could be a container,” Sofia says.
“Yes.”
“With something in it?”
“Containers do encourage that possibility,” Jack says.
Nobody laughs much. Sofia keeps looking at the image, and Jack waits until she looks back at him.
“We don't know,” he says. “That's why it stays where it is.”
“Then that needs to go with the announcement,” Amara says. “Otherwise we will be telling each other by dinner that it was sent to watch us.”
“Before the orbit,” Nora says, “how did it get inside the stone?”
I restore the close view. It is the part I have been accepting without asking. The metal seems to have been waiting inside something our equipment happened to cut open.
Katja gets up and moves beside the table, making space for Sofia to follow the offered geological record.
“The asteroid isn't one solid stone. Look at the pieces around the excavation. Different compositions, fractures, smaller grains between them. A larger body can break apart, and some of its debris can gather again under gravity. An object already among those fragments could end up inside the new body.”
“Like something left in the pocket of a coat,” I say, “except somebody has dismantled the coat and made another one.”
“And we haven't established whose pocket,” Katja says. “Or whether it was put there deliberately.”
Morrow offers the same area before the mining cut. Unbroken material covers the place where the metallic patch will appear. Then the later record returns, with the cutter withdrawn.
“Later impacts can also shift and bury surface material,” it says. “The existing records are compatible with more than one burial process. We have not identified an insertion channel.”
Leila moves a finger along the table while following a fracture in her own view. “Does the rock give you an age?”
“Not yet. An old fragment can cover a recently placed object. The age of the rock is not automatically the age of the burial.”
“But you think it has been there a long time?” Nora asks.
“It's plausible. Establishing a lower age limit needs measurements we do not have.”
Katja brings back the smooth patch. “If that explanation is right, the thing was already here before at least some of the breaking and gathering happened. The stone around it has a history. We haven't found a mark on the part of the metal we can see.”
I look at the jagged grains lying against it. For the first time the smoothness troubles me more than the size. We are still repairing damage from one encounter with a small piece of travelling rock. Here is something enclosed by broken material, with an exposed surface that looks newly made.
“It may have protected itself,” Sofia says.
“Maybe,” Katja replies. “Or we've just uncovered the undamaged bit. I'd like to see more before I fall in love with either explanation.”
“If it was covered on purpose,” Erik says, “then the cover could have a purpose too. I don't want us removing it simply because it gets in the way.”
“Nor do I,” Jack says.
Katja looks from one to the other. “I want to know what's under it. That doesn't mean I want to pull it off.”
Erik nods. “Good. Morrow, where is it, exactly?”
The system's orbits replace the close observations in the offered view. I follow them inward to Violet, then out to a marked body in the asteroid belt beyond Violet, inside the outer gas giant's orbit. Morrow includes the positions at the time of discovery. The marked asteroid continues along its orbit in the model.
“The current one-way signal delay from the ship is twenty minutes,” it says. “The site controller is acting under instructions already received.”
“And you've stopped work there?” Erik asks.
“The cutter remains withdrawn. Nothing is to be removed from that asteroid. Other operations continue outside the exclusion area. I have isolated the site and retained the complete observation history.”
“Any activity from the object?” Jack asks.
“None detected.”
He nods once. “Keep that wording.”
I ask how soon we could get out there. I mean a flight, a close approach, perhaps people in a small craft looking through instruments of their own. The thought comes so readily that I have already begun wondering who should go when Jack answers.
“What could a person do there that the next instrument couldn't?”
“Choose what to look at.”
“Katja can choose that here.”
“With a forty-minute exchange.”
“Which is a problem we can plan for. Putting her beside something we can't explain gives us another one.”
Katja lifts a finger. “I would quite like to be consulted before being put beside it.”
“Would you go?” I ask her.
“Immediately. That's not a risk assessment.”
Jack looks at me again. There is no rebuke in it, which makes it harder to find a useful objection. I have been living with that buried metallic curve for less than an hour. I am willing to send people towards it partly because I want to be one of them.
“You're right,” I say. “I'm getting ahead of myself. Start with what we can send without a crew.”
Sofia asks whether the existing mining units can bring it closer, to equipment already aboard the ship.
“We cannot move it with the means we have there,” Morrow says. “It is embedded in the asteroid. Its full extent and its attachment to the surrounding material are unresolved. The extraction models require cutting through regions we have not mapped.”
“Including the thing itself?”
“In several of them.”
Katja turns towards Sofia. “We might damage it before finding out where its surface continues. We don't know what moving or damaging it would do. It stays where it is.”
The orbit model withdraws at my intention. I want to look at the people making this decision. Erik has his forearms on the table; beside him Leila is still following something in the measurements. Nora has let go of my hand to change into the dry top beneath her loose outer shirt.
Morrow offers its proposed instrument sequence. This time it begins with the broken edge, where the exposed surface is most accessible. A more capable survey craft could observe from several directions without touching the object. The mining units can maintain the cordon and repeat some observations, but they cannot supply the missing measurements.
“Could we equip a craft without taking anything from the repairs?” Erik asks.
“I have not completed that assessment,” Morrow says. “The available flight bus is assigned to resource prospecting. The inspection head would qualify the next precision fabrication line.”
“Which is where the extension fittings are supposed to come from,” Sofia says.
“Among other things.” Erik turns to Katja. “Tell us what you need before we start moving equipment.”
“I can give you questions now. I can't give you a finished mission.”
Nora pulls the damp fabric away from her wrist. “And we need to know how long the other work would wait.”
I had been imagining a vehicle leaving almost at once. Now I follow the flight bus's place in the prospecting programme and the work waiting for the precision line. We can change a design in minutes. Making and testing what it describes still requires equipment somebody else is using.
“Then leave the allocations where they are,” I say. “Katja, will you work through the options with Morrow? The measurements, the risks and what each option would cost.”
“Yes.”
“Morrow?”
“Yes. I would like to investigate it.”
It has already done hours of work beyond what was needed to stop a cutter. I am still caught by the plainness of the answer. Katja glances up towards the sound, then back to me.
“What can the equipment already there do while we consider that?” Erik asks.
“Retain the existing records and continue passive observation from its present position,” Morrow says. “No contact, cutting or additional illumination. I can compare the optical and thermal records over time and refine the orbit from the tracking data.”
“And if something changes?” Jack asks.
“The site controller will report it and keep the equipment clear. It will not attempt to test the response.”
Erik looks around the table. “We'll meet again when we can compare the options, including what each would hold up. Nothing's being reassigned today.”
The adults by the door ask how they will hear about further observations. Amara undertakes to prepare the colony account from the same evidence we have seen, with the failed reconstruction included. Morrow will make the records available. There is no launch date to put in the announcement.
When the meeting breaks up, I reach for Nora's damp top before she can gather everything at once. She gives it to me and remains beside her chair, watching Katja speak quietly to Jack.
“Someone made it,” she says.
“Yes.”
“I keep coming back to that. They knew what it was for. Whoever made it could have looked at this and seen something ordinary.”
I recall the smooth patch and its narrow fringe of colour. For the first time I try to imagine somebody choosing that shape, with a reason as definite as ours for putting handles on a door.
Across the table, Katja asks Morrow to keep the full observation history ready. She has somewhere quiet to go, and questions she did not want to begin in front of everyone. Jack hands her the outer layer she left on a chair. She takes it without looking away from him, says something too softly for me to hear, then goes to find her quiet room.
Nora draws my attention back by pulling at the sleeve I am holding.
“Come on. Sofia's waiting. We still have to put the pipe back.”